NEW YORK CITY, NY – A 17-year-old suspect, who is reportedly Muslim, accused of fatally stabbing a 28-year-old gay black man in late July has been charged with a hate crime over alleged “anti-gay” and “anti-black” comments made leading up to the stabbing. In response to the case, New York City Mayor Eric Adams has claimed the incident is not reflective of the broader perceptions of the LGBT community amidst Muslims.
The originating incident occurred at approximately 11:00 p.m. on July 29th at a gas station located off of Coney Island Avenue, where the victim, identified as O’Shae Sibley, was apparently dancing in his underwear with some friends.
Witnesses claim the 17-year-old suspect, whose name hasn’t been shared by authorities due to his age, confronted the group Sibley was with, claiming the victim’s dancing and state of dress were offensive to him due to his Muslim faith.
A verbal confrontation ensued, with authorities saying the juvenile suspect produced a knife and fatally stabbed Sibley. Summy Ullah, a witness to the original incident, told local news outlets that the juvenile suspect “murdered him because he was gay.”
Following the fatal stabbing, authorities say the involved parties fled the area. However, the juvenile reportedly turned himself into authorities on August 4th without incident. The juvenile is currently facing murder and hate crime charges, as well as a charge for criminal possession of a weapon.
NYPD Detective Bureau Assistant Chief Joe Kenny remarked on the alleged circumstances leading to a hate crime charge against the juvenile, telling reporters, “We have a lot of anti-gay statements and a lot of derogatory statements being made — anti-black, from the defendants. As of right now, the defendant will be charged solely.”
In the wake of the fatal stabbing, speculation was brewing about whether the incident was indicative of the relations between the Muslim and LGBT community, to which community leaders like Muslim activist Sonia Ali claimed this is not the case.
“[T]his is not something that Islam teaches…You don’t take a life, because there’s no reason for you to be doing something like that. This is a free country, you shouldn’t be going and taking [a life]; it’s tragic.”
Mayor Adams mirrored those same sentiments during a press conference on August 5th, telling reporters, “the issue itself made an attempt to give the impression that it came from hate from the Muslim community towards the LGBTQ+ community - that was in fact not true."
The New York City mayor continued with his thoughts on the incident, adding, “These are both important communities in the City of New York. They contribute to the community. Both communities I have worked with on so many occasions, and both are against any level of hate, and both communities have been victimized by Islamophobia, anti-gay and other forms of hate.”
The originating incident occurred at approximately 11:00 p.m. on July 29th at a gas station located off of Coney Island Avenue, where the victim, identified as O’Shae Sibley, was apparently dancing in his underwear with some friends.
Witnesses claim the 17-year-old suspect, whose name hasn’t been shared by authorities due to his age, confronted the group Sibley was with, claiming the victim’s dancing and state of dress were offensive to him due to his Muslim faith.
A verbal confrontation ensued, with authorities saying the juvenile suspect produced a knife and fatally stabbed Sibley. Summy Ullah, a witness to the original incident, told local news outlets that the juvenile suspect “murdered him because he was gay.”
Following the fatal stabbing, authorities say the involved parties fled the area. However, the juvenile reportedly turned himself into authorities on August 4th without incident. The juvenile is currently facing murder and hate crime charges, as well as a charge for criminal possession of a weapon.
NYPD Detective Bureau Assistant Chief Joe Kenny remarked on the alleged circumstances leading to a hate crime charge against the juvenile, telling reporters, “We have a lot of anti-gay statements and a lot of derogatory statements being made — anti-black, from the defendants. As of right now, the defendant will be charged solely.”
In the wake of the fatal stabbing, speculation was brewing about whether the incident was indicative of the relations between the Muslim and LGBT community, to which community leaders like Muslim activist Sonia Ali claimed this is not the case.
“[T]his is not something that Islam teaches…You don’t take a life, because there’s no reason for you to be doing something like that. This is a free country, you shouldn’t be going and taking [a life]; it’s tragic.”
Mayor Adams mirrored those same sentiments during a press conference on August 5th, telling reporters, “the issue itself made an attempt to give the impression that it came from hate from the Muslim community towards the LGBTQ+ community - that was in fact not true."
The New York City mayor continued with his thoughts on the incident, adding, “These are both important communities in the City of New York. They contribute to the community. Both communities I have worked with on so many occasions, and both are against any level of hate, and both communities have been victimized by Islamophobia, anti-gay and other forms of hate.”
For corrections or revisions, click here.
The opinions reflected in this article are not necessarily the opinions of LET
Comments